At present, the current degree of use of place contraptions in Chinese rural countries is merely tantamount to that of the urban countries at the late eightiess ( China Research and Intelligence Co. , 2009 ) . Every 100 Chinese rural families possess the figure of colour TVs, rinsing machines, cell phones and iceboxs merely 2/3, 1/2, 1/2 and 1/4 severally of the of urban families. The asymmetric information between the rural occupant and the electronic place contraption industry consequences in inauspicious choice. This state of affairs imposed the market failure as advancing electronic place contraptions to rural countries. Hence, the subsidy policy of electronic place contraptions for rural countries can be regarded as a policy support by the authorities in order to advance electronic place contraptions and, therefore drive a long-run structural alteration when promoting makers to plan rural usage merchandises ( Credit Suisse, 2009 ) .
In the 3rd one-fourth of 2008, the hazard of 2nd mortgage in the United State provoked the planetary fiscal tsunami. Due to the eruption of the planetary fiscal tsunami, the planetary economic system is in recession and the export of China suffered a great loss. Furthermore, when the fiscal crisis has plunged the universe into recession, protectionism in the Earth market has been on the rise. Harmonizing to a recent World Bank survey, from October 2008 to February 2009, forty seven trade-restricting steps were implemented ( E. Gamberoni and R. Newfarmer, 2009 ) . While the authorization had paid attending on the lifting tide of trade protectionism and recession of export market, by the manner of the primary success of the pilot undertaking and the first extension of the plan in the December 2008, the authorities announced the ” place contraptions to the countryside ” plan would be extended into a national broad graduated table in February 2009 ( Ministry of Finance, Ministry of Commerce and Ministry of Industry and Information Technology, 2008 ) . Harmonizing to the notice, the authorities aims to hike domestic demand to procure economic growing, better populating criterion of the state ‘s rural population, hike domestic ingestion and excite the industrial production growing through the plan extension. Such national broad subsidy policy covers the full rural countries in the state with nine classs of place electronic contraption points.
Significances and purposes of this survey:
After the extension of the “ place contraptions to the countryside ” plan in February 2009, it nationally targeted to the full rural occupants. Harmonizing to the National Bureau of Statistics, the population of rural occupants is 7.2 hundred million about, which is 55.06 % of the population of China ( National Bureau of Statistics, 2008 ) . With this big Numberss of mark participants, how the plan to advance and implement remainders on the authorities and the electronic place contraptions industries.
The Chinese Premier, Wen Jiabao, has commented on the China ‘s stimulus bundle. Harmonizing to his address, ‘the China ‘s stimulus bundle is designed to both sustain economic growing and better people ‘s support ‘ . Policies related to impacting people ‘s wellbeing are given precedence to apportion public resources ( Embassy of China in the US, 2009 ) . Namely, the authorization regards the subsidy policy a important scheme to increase domestic demand and procure the economic growing under the current economic system circumstance and besides a policy that besides aims to better the populating criterion of the rural occupants. Ministry of Commerce estimations that the “ place contraptions to the countryside ” plan will hike domestic ingestion and achieves RMB 150 billion in the first twelvemonth and wholly hike RMB 920 billion at the terminal of the plan. However, comparison with the approximative RMB 150 billion rural disbursement, the proportion is comparatively little. During the first 10 month of 2009, the national gross revenues of the subsidy plan was 2787.8 units which accounted for RMB 5.08 billion. Within this period, the gross revenues figure record a continued dropping in August and September while the gross revenues in August was around RMB 7.6 billion, and it was every bit low as RMB 6.2 billion in September. ( People ‘s Daily, 2009 ) . It was the first clip of a continued two months gross revenues decline from the RMB 8.8 billion gross revenues in the July. These figures reveal that the result of the subsidy plan is non able to run into the original estimate. This indicated the original appraisal is excessively optimistic and overvalues the engagements of rural occupants.
The subsidy policy is a comprehensive scheme affecting big Numberss of rural occupants and big sum of money. The participants of the rural occupants are the cardinal fundamental of the subsidy policy. Rural occupants will non blindly devour what the electronic place contraption industry put on the market despite there is a 13 % subsidy from the authorities. They have their concerns and ratings to the policy.
This survey chiefly focuses on the “ place contraptions to the countryside ” plan after February 2009 and its purposes to analysis the relationship among the authorities, the electronic place contraption industry and rural occupants. For the authorities, the plan is to hike domestic ingestion in the rural country to procure economic growing. For the electronic place contraption makers, they aim to derive benefits. For the rural occupants, they consider to better their life criterion after buying the electronic place contraptions through a subsided monetary value. By analyzing their different intents to take part in the plan, I will seek to reason some suggestion to heighten the efficiency of the “ place contraptions to the countryside ” plan since the result is non satisfied with the false appraisal.
“ Home contraptions to the countryside ” plan
The English interlingual rendition as ‘ ” place contraptions to the countryside ” plan ‘ was officially used in the authorities and media in China. The plan foremost started as a pilot undertaking on three states and one metropolis in December 2007. After keeping the pilot undertaking for one twelvemonth, in December 2008, phrase one of the “ place contraptions to the countryside ” plan which extended its country to a sum of 14 states, straight controlled municipalities and independent parts was started. At last, in the February 2009, the plan extends to full rural countries in the state and to subsidise the rural occupants in nine classs of electronic place contraptions ( colour Television sets, iceboxs, nomadic phones, rinsing machines, air conditioners, H2O warmers, computing machines, microwave ovens and electromagnetic cookers ) . The plan will last for four old ages to 2012 and rural occupants were entitled to a 13 % subsidy on buying the selected electronic place contraptions ( limited within two units in each class ) . Since this subsidy plan targeted the rural occupants, merely those with rural residence qualify for the subsidies. Harmonizing to ordinances of runing the “ place contraptions to the countryside ” plan, a monetary value bound was set on each class. ( For illustration, colour Television set RMB3500, iceboxs RMB2500, nomadic phone RMB1000, rinsing machines RMB2000, etc ) . The original intent to put up such bound is to guarantee points are low-cost to the rural occupants. However, this bound was regarded as one of the factors that hinder to accomplish the approximative rural outgo.
The “ place contraptions to countryside ” plan has been running for more than 10 months since February 2009 and different sorts of statistics were announced. Harmonizing to the Ministry of Commerce, there are 17 place electronic contraptions companies which has accumulated gross revenues over 100 million and they include Haier, Gree, Midea, Skyworth, Konka, TCL, Lenovo, etc. Among these companies, Haier is the endeavor which benefits the most from subsidy plan and has the highest accrued gross revenues figures of RMB 8.6 billion during the past 10 months. However, there are still 14 companies out of 348 which show break uping gross revenues while another 17 endeavors sold less than 10 units ( Minister of Commerce 2009 ) .
Indexs of quality of unrecorded
As mentioned earlier in this survey, the subsidy plan in besides a societal public assistance plan. This policy supports the rural occupants to purchase electronic place contraptions in order to better their life criterion. David E. Bloom, Patricia H. Craig and Pia N. Malaney in their survey concluded several indexs to measure quality of life. They are ‘nutrition ‘ , ‘health ‘ , ‘education ‘ , ‘income ‘ , ‘gender equality ‘ , ‘fertility ‘ , ‘political, civil, and economic freedom ‘ , ‘environmental quality ‘ , ‘access to substructure ‘ , and ‘access to information ‘ .
Televisions and nomadic phone convenience their life and besides supply a channel for them to derive information. Industries are required to add particular maps which are fit to utilize in rural environment. The theoretical accounts of Mobile phone which selected in the plan are required to heighten the signal accessing ability where signal from web operators in rural environment are instability. In the long tally, the intent of the subsidy plan is steering the industries to put up production line for rural markets. As a consequence, when the plan ends in 2012, the subsidy plan is expected to actuate the production of the electronic place contraptions sector, meanwhile, excite the industrial construction development.
Consumption behaviour in rural countries
The “ place contraptions to the countryside ” plan is a scheme to hike domestic ingestion by promoting the rural occupants to devour more. By understanding the ingestion behaviour of the rural occupants, the authorities can gauge their contemplation and therefore the efficiency of policies can be guaranteed.
Since there are assorted hierarchy of demand, people would utilize their income to purchase the basic survival resources as their precedence while the development merchandises would be subsequent and following by the leisure goods ( W.H. Wong, 1999 ) . In other words, there is a sequence of devouring. W. Guo concluded the basic sequence of spread outing disbursement of rural occupants in his survey ( W. Guo 1998 ) . It is: reproduction goods, lodging, and instruction for theyounger coevals, transit, electronic place contraptions, and trade goods. Under this sequence of devouring, we can foretell the ingestion behaviour of rural families.
Basically, personal disposable income subtraction personal economy is personal ingestion outgo ( N. Gregory Manki, 2004 ) . Therefore, personal disposable income becomes one of the factors that affect personal ingestion outgo. Wong in his survey indicated that, the ingestion power and purpose to pass are different in different degree of household income. Rural families of high flat income prefer to devour to increase populating standard. On the contrast, rural families of low income degree tendency to carry through basic demand because of constraining by the limed of income.
When the rural occupants can carry through their basic demand, they who are mobilized by the subsidy plan are able to devour the electronic place contraptions.
Insecurity income beginning due to deficient in land usage
Harmonizing to the World Bank, 90 % of poorness is still rural excepting migratory workers from the rural population ( World Bank, 2009 ) . Although per capital net income of rural families has been being steady lifting these old ages, the income spread between the urban and rural has besides grown. Harmonizing to the National Bureau of Statistic, in 2007 the per capital one-year net income of urban families is around RMB 14908, meanwhile, the per capital one-year net income of rural families is around RMB 4140, which is merely 27.7 % of the urban families ( National Bureau of Statistic, 2008 ) . Furthermore, the rural family does non experience a sense of security on their income beginning since they merely have usage rights to but make non have the land themselves. In add-on, the long-run investing in land is demotivated because of the insecurity of usage rights ( Jacoby H. , Li G. , Rozelle, S. , 2002 ) . Because of the ingestion outgo related to the personal income, in income of rural families are non security, they prefer to nest eggs instead than ingestion. It can be regarded one of the factors that demoviated the rural occupants to take part in the “ place contraption to countryside ” plan.
Coverage of Social Security is low in rural countries
Harmonizing to China Social Security Annual Bulletin, in 2007, there were about 476 million people in China ‘s rural labour force. However, in that twelvemonth, the Numberss of workers contributed to the old age pension system was fewer than 52 million and merely 11 per centum of the rural labour force was covered by the strategy ( Y. Yang, J.B. Williamson, C. Shen, 2009 ) . Scholars conclude the old age pension system does non hold dependable beginning of funding, and full of jobs of financess embezzlement and is low benefits ( I. Nielsen, C. Nyland, R. Smyth, M.Q. Zhang and C. J. Zhu, 2005 ) . Since they do non and are non force to lend to the old age pension. The rural occupants rely on their nest eggs as their hazard protection. As a consequence, the attractive force to the rural occupants of the 13 % subsidy from the plan will diminish and the engagement of the rural will be affected.
Game theory is a survey of the ways in whichstrategic interactionsamongrational playersproduceoutcomeswith regard to theutilities of those participants ( Daniel Burgess, 2005 ) . In other words, game theory analyses how agents ( participants ) make determination which sufficient their ain public-service corporations instrategic state of affairss ( games ) . It is a mathematic theory which can be applied toin thesocial scientific disciplines research. It emphases that each participant involved in game will gauge their benefits and Acts of the Apostless in order to derive the best result separately. If in a state of affairs where it is non possible to increase benefits merely by the execution of one individual participant, this scheme is called the Nash equilibrium. Players involved in game relation will merely seek to profit oneself, it sometimes leads to a state of affairs of captive quandary. In such state of affairs, people do non collaborate although by so they can do both of them to be better off. ‘The efficiency of a policy depends on the coherency between the Nash equilibrium and policy shaper ‘s ideal focal point ‘ ( Osborne, Martin J. & A ; Rubinstein, Ariel, 2003 ) . Every participant involves a policy will do different picks which affect the result and efficiency of a policy. As a consequence, we can utilize the decision by analysing game theoretical accounts of each participant to better the efficiency of a policy.
The “ place contraptions to the countryside ” plan has double maps. On one manus, it is an economic policy that emphases on keeping economic system growing by hiking domestic ingestion. On the other manus, it is a societal public assistance policy that accents on bettering the populating criterion of rural occupants by subsidising them to buy electronic place contraptions. The authorities, the electronic place contraptions industry and the rural occupants can take their ain schemes to take part to the “ place contraptions to countryside ” plan. This survey argues the game dealingss among the participants of the “ place contraptions to countryside ” plan will impede the rural occupants to take part to the plan. As a consequence, the expected result of the subsidy plan will be held back.
As mentioned before, harmonizing to the game theory, the efficiency of a policy depends on the coherency between the Nash equilibrium and policy shaper ‘s ideal focal point. The spread between the aims and consequences of the policy originated from the game dealingss among the participants. Although the authorities has had a good purpose, the consequences of the plan gained at present were non conforming to the original appraisal. In this survey, a game-theoretic theoretical account is used to analyze the relationships among rural occupants, endeavors and authoritiess under the policy that rural occupants are encouraged to take part to the subsidy plan. The authorities can take to optimise the plan in order to pull more rural occupants to take part and devour. The rural occupant can take to or non to take part in the plan by ciphering their benefit and loss. As each participant seeks to fulfill its public-service corporation, this plan can be analyzed as an n-person non-cooperative game. This paper tries to relocate the functions of authoritiess, and set frontward some policy suggestion on advancing the “ place contraptions to the countryside ” plan.
In research methodological analysis, I will utilize informations analysis every bit good as papers analysis methods to analyse in which countries the authorities should better the “ place contraptions to the countryside ” plan. The Ministry of Commerce and the National Bureau of Statistics have been proclaiming informations about the subsidy plan each month. Furthermore, Thought these informations, the game dealingss among the participants in the plan ( including the authorities, the industry and rural occupants ) can be examined. Since the subsidy plan is extremely concerned by the populace. Scholars have been investigated and commented on the plan. Their researches can lend to relevance the game relation among the participants.
Full text of Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao ‘s address at 2009 Summer Davos in Dalian ‘ . ( 2009 ) , Embassy of the People ‘s Republic of China in the United States of America. Avaliable online: hypertext transfer protocol: //www.china-embassy.org/chn/zt/t583718.htm ( accessed 4 November 2009 )
Guanyu quanguo tuiguang jia dian xia xiang gongzuo de tongzhi ‘ ( Notice from three authorities sections about the national implementtiona of ‘home contraptions to the countryside ‘ plan ‘ ) , Ministry of Finance, Ministry of Commerce, and Ministry of Industry and Information Technology of China. Available online: hypertext transfer protocol: //www.gov.cn/gzdt/2008-12/05/content_1169347.htm ( accessed 30 October 2009 )
Jia dian xia xiang yun niang zheng Ce tiao zheng, zhong biao chi ye jiang you tao Thai zhi ” , Ministry of Commerce, China.
Caidian hangye juyu yu tiaozhan bingcun ‘ ( The Color Television industry: Opportunities and Challenges ) , Ceneral Administration of Customs of China. Available online: hypertext transfer protocol: //www.customs.gov.cn:82/gate/big5/www.customs.gov.cn/Portals/0/jcyj/-ifbase4-base76-vfHE6jG8vrbIztK5+rLKteez9r-awb-D98-Uz8K9tbLKtefQ0NK1u-rT9tPrzPTVvbKitOYuZG9j ( accessd 20 November 2009 )
Xiaoshou yu ladong neisu yuqi you cha ju, “ jiadian xiiaxiang ” yunniang tiaozheng ‘ ( Gap between the Gross saless and the estimated ingestion, ‘home contraptions to the state ‘ plan is brew to set ) . Renmin ribao ( People ‘s Daily ) . 19 November 2009
Daniel Burgess, ( 2005 ) ‘Utilitarianism, Game Theory and the Social Contract ‘ , Macalester Journal of Philosophy, Volume 14, Issue 1. P.75
Elisa Gamberoni and Richard Newfarmer. ( 2009 ) ‘Trade Protection: Incipient but Worrisome Trend ‘ , Trade Notes.
Ingrid Nielsen, Chris Nyland, Russell Smyth, Mingqiong Zhang and Cherrie Jiuhua Zhu ( 2005 ) . “ Which Rural Migrants Receive Social Insurance in Chinese Cites? “ , Sage: Global Social polic, P.353-381
Jacoby, H. , Li, G. , Rozelle, S. , ( 2002 ) ‘Hazards of expropriation: term of office insecurity and investing in rural China ‘ . American Economic Review, v. 92, n. 5, p. 1.420-1.447.
National Bureau of Statistics of China. ( 2008 ) ‘Population and Composition ‘ , China Statistical Yearbook 2008. 3-1, 9-5, and 9-20. Available online: hypertext transfer protocol: //www.stats.gov.cn/tjsj/ndsj/2008/indexce.htm ( accessed 4 Nov )
N. Gregory Mankiw. ( 2004 ) ‘Principles of Economics ‘ , Thomson Learning, Chapter 26.
Osborne, Martin J. & A ; Rubinstein, Ariel. ( 2003 ) ‘Sampling equilibrium, with an application to strategic vote ‘ . Games and Economic Behavior, P.434-441.
Study Group of Asia Technology Research Analyst Team. ( 2009 ) , ‘China ‘s electronics subsidy programme ‘ , Credit Suisse.
Study Group of China Research and Intelligence Co. ( 2009 ) ‘Research Report on Chinese Home Appliance Manufacturing Industry, 2008-2009 ‘ , China Research and Intelligence Co.
Wang Guanqun. ( 2009 ) ‘Home contraptions shapers catch their breath as rural gross revenues roar ‘ ( text ) , Xinhua News, 31 May. Available online: hypertext transfer protocol: //news.xinhuanet.com/english/2009-05/31/content_11463552.htm ( accessed 4 November2009 ) .
Wei Guo. ( 1998 ) ‘Non cun shi Chang Jiang he yi qi Er bu dong ‘ , Jing Jemaah Islamiyah xue xin xi bao. China.
Weihong Wong. ( 1999 ) ‘Zhong guo nong cun ju min xiao fei de ji ben qu shi Jemaah Islamiyah zhi Yue nong min xiao fei xing wei dei Jemaah Islamiyah ben yin su fen xi ‘ ( An analyze of factors that constructs to the ingestion behaviour in rural country of China ) , National Economic Research Institute, China Reform Foundation. P.13
World Bank. ( 2009 ) China, From Poor Areas to Poor People. China: World Bank.
Yinan Yang, John B. Williamson, Ce Shen ( 2009. ) ‘Social security for China ‘s rural aged: a proposal based on a universal on conducive pension ‘ , International Journal of Social Welfare.